Masterbuilt Electric Smoker vs Char-Broil vs Smoke Hollow – Which Is Best?

Masterbuilt Electric Smoker vs Char-Broil vs Smoke Hollow

Electric smokers are incredibly easy to use and it’s okay to leave them alone for an extended period of time. This makes them ideal for someone who wants to smoke meat, but does not want to be tied to their smoker the whole time.

They cost less than gas smokers, are easy to use, and offer convenience that is unrivaled by any other kind of smoker on the market.

When you want to produce quality smoked meats in the comfort of your own backyard, you need an electric smoker to make the task easy and enjoyable.

That is why we decided to compare the Masterbuilt Electric Smoker vs Char-broil vs Smoke Hollow smokers in a head to head comparison

Price Comparison

$134.24
$219.99
16 new from $134.24
as of July 21, 2018 2:58 pm
Amazon.com
Free shipping
$184.29
$203.51
13 new from $179.91
6 used from $156.65
as of July 21, 2018 2:58 pm
Amazon.com
Free shipping
$204.08
24 new from $204.08
1 used from $183.67
as of July 21, 2018 2:58 pm
Amazon.com
Free shipping

Compare Specs

Important Features
Masterbuilt Electric Smoker
VS
Char-Broil
VS
Smoke Hollow
Temperature Control
Adjustable
VS
Adjustable
VS
3 Settings
Cooking Racks
4
VS
4
VS
3
Window Viewing
VS
VS
Thermostat
VS
VS
Warranty
90 Days
VS
1 Year
VS
1 Year

Compare The Masterbuilt Electric Smoker Against The Char-Broil And The Smoke Hollow Smokers

Specification Comparison and Reviews

You can take the guesswork out of finding the best electric smoker for your use when you compare three main features. Ranking these features from 1-100 makes finding the smoker that will meet your needs, without breaking the bank, a breeze and a lot of fun.

Window

Most people like to keep an eye on their food while it’s smoking, but every time you open the door you are going to let out a lot of heat. When you do this, you simply make the smoker work harder to come back up to the temperature and that can actually increase the amount of time that it will take for your food to cook. You can avoid this problem when you opt for an electric smoker that has a glass panel or window so that you can keep an eye on your food without disrupting the cooking process.

Masterbuilt Electric Smoker

Without a window you will be forced to open the door if you want to peek at your food. While this unit will come back up to a hot temperature fairly quickly, anytime you open the door you risk lowering the temperature and making the smoker work harder.

Char-Broil Electric Smoker

This smoker has a large window that takes up most of the space on the front of the smoker. This is great because over-eager users can satisfy their curiosity about how their food is doing without opening the door to peek and accidentally lowering the internal temperature.

Smoke Hollow Electric Smoker

Not including a window is a bit of an oversight for this smoker, as it would make it so much easier to see inside and check on the condition of your meat. It’s important to resist the temptation to open the door and peek so you don’t drop the temperature.

Winner

Masterbuilt Electric Smoker 50Points
Char-Broil 90Points
Smoke Hollow 50Points

Point Totals

Masterbuilt Electric Smoker – 50

Char-Broil Electric Smoker – 90

Smoke Hollow Electric Smoker – 50

As the only smoker on this list with a window, the clear winner for this feature is the Charbroil Electric Smoker. This will satisfy your curiosity while you are smoking meat and prevent you from opening the door on a regular basis. This is also a great way to get your kids involved with the smoking process, as being able to see what’s going on is a lot more interesting for kids and will hold their interest.

Temperature Control

No matter if you are going to be spending all afternoon babysitting your new smoker when it’s working or if you want to be able to leave your home and run errands, you will want to make sure that you have great temperature control. This will allow you to make adjustments as needed and will ensure that the smoker is operating at the right temperature all day long. Quality temperature control will make a huge difference in the overall quality of your meat when you are finished smoking it.

Masterbuilt Electric Smoker

You’ll love the digital control panel on this smoker. All you have to do is enter the temperature that you want the smoker to maintain, as well as the time you need the smoker to run. With just this information, your smoker will produce incredible results.

Char-Broil Electric Smoker

You can rely on the advanced control panel to set the temperature that you want your food to cook to and insert the probe into your meat. Now your smoker will alert you when your meat has finished cooking so that you don’t have to worry about it drying out.

Smoke Hollow Electric Smoker

You have to keep an eye on this smoker as it does have a built-in thermometer, but doesn’t offer a lot of temperature control. Maintaining a consistent temperature can be a little trickier with this smoker.

Winner

Masterbuilt Electric Smoker 70Points
Char-Broil 85Points
Smoke Hollow 50Points

Point Totals

Masterbuilt Electric Smoker – 70

Char-Broil Electric Smoker – 85

Smoke Hollow Electric Smoker – 50

You’ll love that you can set and forget the Charbroil Electric Smoker and that it has a probe for monitoring the internal temperature of your meat. You’ll never have to worry about dried-out meat when you choose this smoker as it makes it so easy to keep an eye on the temperature, thanks to the large and easy to read LCD screen. You can count on this smoker to create perfectly cooked meat every single time.

Water Pan

For the ultimate in juicy meat and to be able to add flavor to your food while it is smoking you will want to make sure that there is a water pan and that it’s not only big enough to handle a large amount of liquid, but also that you can easily get to it without the risk of burning yourself when the smoker is on. A water pan has to be able to withstand high temperatures and you want to make sure that grease will not drip into the water while your meat is smoking.

Masterbuilt Electric Smoker

The water pan that comes with this smoker is large enough to easily add water and not worry about it again while the meat is smoking. This will allow you to fill the pan once and then leave the smoker to work on its own.

Char-Broil Electric Smoker

The slide-in water pan easily holds enough water for when you are smoking meat. You won’t have to worry about burning your hand when using the water pan or about accidentally spilling grease in it because of the way it is placed in the smoker.

Smoke Hollow Electric Smoker

The small water pan is so little that you will have to replace the water inside of it regularly throughout the day. This is not only time consuming, but it also means that you will risk being burned each time you reach into the smoker.

Masterbuilt Electric Smoker 75Points
Char-Broil 70Points
Smoke Hollow 50Points

Point Totals

Masterbuilt Electric Smoker – 75

Char-Broil Electric Smoker – 70

Smoke Hollow Electric Smoker – 50

In this case, the Masterbuilt electric smoker comes out on top. This smoker gets great reviews from users about the size of the water pan, as well as how easy it is to add water to it during cooking.

It is very unlikely that you will need to do this, as the pan can hold so much water, but if you do want to add water or juice to affect the flavor of your meat you can easily do that without any trouble.

Final Score

Masterbuilt Electric Smoker – 195

Char-Broil Electric Smoker – 245

Smoke Hollow Electric Smoker – 150

The Charbroil Electric Smoker is the clear winner here and for good reason. You won’t ever have to guess or wonder if your meat is done when you use this smoker.

Not only can you easily keep an eye on your meat through the handy window, but the probe will let you know when your meat has reached the desired internal temperature. No need to worry about having to rush to get your meat out of the smoker, as the smoker will automatically turn on a warming feature to keep your food warm until you are ready to take it out and serve it.

Masterbuilt Electric Smoker

Positives
  • Plenty Of Space
  • Meat Probe
  • Great Recipes Included
  • Maneuverable

Negatives
  • Availability
  • Remote Difficulties

Positives
  • Meat Probe
  • Stainless Steel
  • Good Mobility
  • Large Cooking Space

Negatives
  • Remote Control Problems
  • Not Good In Cold Weather

Positives
  • Heavy Duty Frame
  • Helpful Smoker Manual
  • Temperature Gauge
  • Steam Pan

Negatives
  • Heavy Unit
  • Not Energy Efficient

Our Choice

When comparing the Masterbuilt Electric Smoker against the Char-Broil and the Smoke Hollow smokers we feel that you can’t go wrong with Char-Broil Electric Smoker but it is more expensive. If money is no obstacle, then we choose the Char-Broil Smoker.

For More Information About Gas Grills And For The Best Price Online, Check Out These Articles

Gray Duke is the staff writer on 3 successful websites and is now taking his skill as a writer and using it to help non-profit organizations and leaders around the world.