Masterbuilt Propane Smoker vs Electric Smoker – Which Is Better?

Masterbuilt Propane Smoker vs Electric Smoker

Buying a smoker allows you to cook fantastic food in your backyard and get the same taste and quality that you would enjoy from a restaurant, without having to either go out to eat or pay their exorbitant prices.

These smokers are great for anyone who is looking for a new and different way to cook their food. You don’t get into a rut at dinner, and these smokers make it easy for both amateurs and experts to create fantastic flavor without much hassle.

That is why we decided to compare the Masterbuilt Propane Smoker and the Masterbuilt Electric Smoker in a head to head comparison

Compare Specs

Important Features
Masterbuilt Propane Smoker
VS
Masterbuilt Electric Smoker
Fuel Type
Gas
VS
Electric
Smoking SpaceSquare Inches
730
VS
Up To 2 Turkeys (Sq. Inches Unavailable)
Racks
4
VS
4
Temperature RangeFahrenheit
175 - 350
VS
100 to 275
Thermostat
VS
Temperature Guage
VS

Compare The Masterbuilt Propane Smoker and The Masterbuilt Electric Smoker

Specification Comparison and Reviews

Image of smoked meat created by the best meat smoker for home use.It can be tricky to compare smokers, especially when you are looking at ones that are very different from each other.

Using a point system from 1-100 to compare these smokers is a great idea. This will allow you to see the ranking of two smokers and then you can more easily choose the one that will meet your needs.

Fuel Type

The fuel is what is going actually to heat and smoke your meat. Many people have strong opinions about what kind of fuel is the best for smoking.

If you are a little on the fence about electric vs. propane smokers then understanding the pros and cons of each will help you to make the best decision for your home.

Remember: what works for you may not work well for a neighbor, so it’s up to you to decide what kind of fuel will best meet your needs.

Masterbuilt 20050716 Thermotemp Propane Smoker

This smoker relies on propane to heat and cooks the meat; it also has a drawer where you can add wood chips to change the flavor.

These smokers don’t require electricity, which makes them useful while you are camping. You can also get these smokers to incredibly high temperatures.

Masterbuilt 20077615 Digital Electric Smoker

Electric smokers take a while to heat up. Once they do, there isn’t any problem with them holding a consistent temperature, no matter what the weather is like outside. They are generally lightweight and often have drawers for adding flavored wood chips, as well.

Winner

Masterbuilt Propane Smoker 90Points
Masterbuilt Electric Smoker 80Points

Point Totals

Masterbuilt 20050716 Thermotemp Propane Smoker – 90

Masterbuilt 20077615 Digital Electric Smoker – 80

When most people want to buy a smoker they want something that will give them the authentic feel and flavor of smoked food, so they opt for a propane smoker.

If you are not so worried about that and are more concerned with the reliability of your smoker, then you may be happier with an electric smoker. In this case, it is hard to decide upon a clear winner due to personal preference, but the propane smoker continually comes out ahead due to the incredible flavor that it can produce.

Temperature Control

It’s essential that you have complete control over the temperature inside your smoker, as you want to make sure that your meat will turn out correctly. Different smokers often come with very different temperature monitoring and control, but the one that you choose will play a huge role in the outcome of the food that you make.

Unless you want to spend all day babysitting your smoker, you will want to opt for one that can take care of the temperature on its own.

Masterbuilt 20050716 Thermotemp Propane Smoker

While most propane smokers require constant attention and adjusting to keep the temperature perfect during smoking, this Masterbuilt propane smoker doesn’t. It has a reliable thermostat to control the temperature and will manage the burner to maintain your desired heat for the duration of cooking.

Masterbuilt 20077615 Digital Electric Smoker

Using the included control, you can easily monitor not just the temperature of the smoker itself, but also the meat inside. This ensures that you can remove the meat when it is finished smoking so that you don’t have to worry about it being overcooked and dry.

Winner

Masterbuilt Propane Smoker 90Points
Masterbuilt Electric Smoker 75Points

Point Totals

Masterbuilt 20050716 Thermotemp Propane Smoker – 90

Masterbuilt 20077615 Digital Electric Smoker – 75

Here the Masterbuilt propane smoker comes out ahead just because it does such a great job at monitoring and adjusting the internal temperature for you.

Unlike other propane smokers where you have to be incredibly involved to ensure that your food doesn’t cook at too high or too low of a temperature, with this model you will enjoy perfect results every time you use it.

This will remove a lot of the stress that you feel when trying to smoke your food and you’re sure to love that you can set and forget your smoker and let it do all the work.

Temperature Range

It’s important to consider what temperature range you will have when smoking meat because you want to make sure that you can go as low or as high as you want. This will allow you to smoke your meat, but also to vary the temperature that you use so that you can make sure that you are smoking your meat at the best temperature range.

For example, it is recommended to smoke chicken and beef loin at higher temperatures than ribs or pork butt, and being able to make these adjustments can make a world of a difference in the final quality of your meat.

Masterbuilt 20050716 Thermotemp Propane Smoker

Propane smokers are, by default, able to get much hotter than electric smokers can. This is useful not only when you want to smoke something at a higher temperature, but also when you are trying to smoke in the winter and have to deal with cold air trying to lower the temperature of your smoker.

Masterbuilt 20077615 Digital Electric Smoker

This smoker provides consistent smoking at an even temperature up to 275 degrees F. While this will easily handle most of the food that you want to smoke, some foods are recommended to be smoked at up to 300 degrees F. For the best results, you will want to be able to have complete temperature control.

Masterbuilt Propane Smoker 85Points
Masterbuilt Electric Smoker 70Points

Point Totals

Masterbuilt 20050716 Thermotemp Propane Smoker – 85

Masterbuilt 20077615 Digital Electric Smoker – 70

The Masterbuilt propane smoker can get to higher temperatures and to hold them consistently, which makes it easy for you to control your smoker and find the sweet spot for anything you want to smoke.

While some people may be happier with an electric smoker that doesn’t offer quite the same high heat, if you want to have complete control over your smoking, then you will want to opt for the propane smoker so that you can smoke at higher temperatures without any problems.

Final Score

Masterbuilt 20050716 Thermotemp Propane Smoker – 265

Masterbuilt 20077615 Digital Electric Smoker – 225

Overall, propane smokers can be more challenging to use than electric smokers, but that’s not the case with the Masterbuilt 20050716 Thermotemp Propane Smoker.

This smoker is incredibly powerful and easy to use, making it perfect no matter how much experience you have with smoking meat. No matter how involved you want to be with the smoking process or if you want to set the smoker and walk away, this propane smoker will more than meet your needs. It makes it easy to produce excellent food time after time consistently.

Masterbuilt Propane Smoker

Positives
  • Door For Wood Chips
  • Secondary Shut Off Valve
  • Plenty Of Smoking Area
  • Smoking Guide

Negatives
  • Smaller Wood Chip Pan
  • Higher Learning Curve

Masterbuilt Electric Smoker

Positives
  • Plenty Of Space
  • Meat Probe
  • Great Recipes Included
  • Maneuverable

Negatives
  • High Temperature Limits
  • Remote Control Difficulties

Our Choice

When comparing the Masterbuilt Propane Smoker and the Masterbuilt Electric Smoker, we feel the choice depends upon your experience. You can’t go wrong with the propane smoker but it takes more time to learn how to smoke your meat right, and the electric smoker does an excellent job as well. If you are willing to learn, then we choose the Masterbuilt Propane Smoker.

For More Information About Masterbuilt Smokers And For The Best Price Online, Check Out These Articles

Read This Masterbuilt Propane Smoker vs Electric Smoker Comparison To Discover The Information YOU Are Searching For. We Have The Best Meat Smoker Comparisons On The Net! #food #cooking #cookingtips #Smokedmeat #meatsmokers #TabersBestReviews

Duke Taber is the owner of 3 successful websites and is now taking his skill as a writer and using it to help non-profit organizations and leaders around the world.

      Pin
      Share
      Tweet