Weber Smokey Mountain vs Kamado vs Traeger – Which Is The Best Smoker?

Weber Smokey Mountain vs Kamado vs Traeger

Being able to smoke your meat in your backyard will ensure that you can have the best BBQ whenever you want it – without having to go to a restaurant or order it online. Whenever the mood strikes, you can heat up your smoker and make some of the best-smoked pork, beef, or chicken.

By experimenting to find the right combination of ingredients for marinades and sauces, you’re sure to come up with a signature dish everyone will love. Buying the best quality griller smoker will ensure that your dreams come true.

That is why we decided to compare the Weber Smokey Mountain vs. Kamado vs. Traeger in a head to head comparison

Price Comparison

$299.99
$312.11
in stock
14 new from $299.99
1 used from $293.99
as of November 14, 2018 10:12 pm
Amazon.com
Free shipping
$386.99
$429.99
in stock
1 new from $386.99
1 used from $348.99
as of November 14, 2018 10:12 pm
Amazon.com
Free shipping
$399.00
$499.00
in stock
9 new from $399.00
as of November 14, 2018 10:12 pm
Amazon.com
Free shipping

Compare Specs

Important Features
Weber Smokey Mountain
VS
Kamado
VS
Traeger
Fuel Type
Charcoal
VS
Charcoal
VS
Wood Pellets
Cooking SpaceSquare Inches
726
VS
447
VS
300
Ignition System
Manual
VS
Manual
VS
Electric
Thermostat
VS
VS
Insulation
Single Wall
VS
Triple Wall
VS
Single Wall

Compare The Weber Smokey Mountain And The Kamado Smoker And The Traeger Smoker

Specification Comparison and Reviews

It’s effortless to find the best griller smoker combination unit when you compare different ones and their features. By using a point scale from 1-100, you can quickly figure out which one is the apparent winner. This ensures that you don’t waste your time or money when shopping.

Versatility

Rather than buying a piece of equipment that can only operate as a smoker or only work as a grill, when you buy one that is very versatile, you will get more for your money. Additionally, you won’t have to find extra storage space in your home or garage for the additional pieces of equipment, as you can use one item for a myriad of purposes. You’ll love being able to cook in more than one way with a versatile smoker griller.

Weber Smokey Mountain

When you buy this smoker you won’t just use it to smoke meat – it can also be used as a grill. This means that you get twice the cooking options, but you only have to buy one piece of equipment.

Char-Griller Kamado

Just like the Weber, the Kamado from Char-Griller operates as a grill and as a smoker. Whether you want to roast your meat or quickly sear your steak for a special meal, you can use this griller smoker to meet your needs.

Traeger Smoker

For extreme versatility in how you prepare your food, the Traeger is perfect. Grill, bake, smoke, braise, roast, and BBQ your food to perfection. You can quickly adapt this smoker griller to meet your needs and to make fantastic food that everyone is sure to love.

Winner

Weber Smokey Mountain 60Points
Kamado 60Points
Traeger 90Points

Point Totals

Weber Smokey Mountain – 60

Char-Griller Kamado – 60

Traeger Smoker – 90

The Traeger Smoker is the clear winner here since it can be used in so many different ways. As the most versatile of the three options, you won’t ever struggle with getting this smoker griller to meet your needs.

No matter if you want to throw a pizza in it for a quick bake or grill or roast some chicken all afternoon, this one will meet your needs and exceed your expectations. You’ll love how easy it is to get this unit to work the way that you want it to.

Insulation

Great insulation will help to keep the heat an even temperature inside your griller smoker. No matter how cold it is outside when you have quality insulation – and enough of it – you won’t have to worry about continually adding fuel. This will also give you peace of mind knowing that your food won’t take all day to cook, no matter what the temperature is outside.

Weber Smokey Mountain

While this is a great smoker cooker, it only offers single wall insulation. This means that when the weather gets cold out, it can be challenging to keep the unit at the right temperature while you are smoking.

Char-Griller Kamado

Enjoy triple-walled insulation for the best heat retention that you can count on. You won’t ever have to worry about your smoker griller dropping in temperature, even when the weather turns bad. Save your money on fuel when you rely on the three layers of insulation.

Traeger Smoker

Although this smoker only has one layer of insulation, there is a special blanket that you can buy that will wrap up the smoker griller during the winter. This will keep you from wasting fuel and ensure an even temperature.

Winner

Weber Smokey Mountain
Kamado
Traeger

Point Totals

Weber Smokey Mountain – 50

Char-Griller Kamado – 80

Traeger Smoker – 65

With three layers of 22-gauge steel insulation, you won’t have to worry about the food in your Char-Griller Kamado getting cold during the cooking process. Because the air inside will stay nice and hot even when it is freezing outside, you also won’t have to worry about an increase in fuel use.

This will ensure that you save money over the life of this smoker griller. You can depend on temperatures from 200-700 degrees F no matter how cold it is outside.

Temperature Monitoring and Control

Whether you are going to be smoking or grilling your meat, you will want to make sure that you have complete control over the temperature and that you can easily monitor the heat so that you don’t have to worry about fluctuations. Significant fluctuations can have a negative impact on the final quality of the meat that you make and can result in having to start over with fresh meat.

Weber Smokey Mountain

This griller smoker comes with a built-in thermometer that makes it easy to check the temperature. You can control the heat by adding more fuel, if necessary. If it is too warm, you will need to open vents to release some air.

Char-Griller Kamado

The adjustable dampers are located on the top and bottom of this unit to make temperature control easy. You’ll enjoy the easy to read thermometer that is built right into the lid, so you don’t have to use another thermometer or lift the cover for a reading.

Traeger Smoker

Enjoy perfect temperature control due to the Digital Elite Controller that will allow you to set and maintain ideal temperatures. With a variance of +/- 20 degrees, you can still count on much control when you use this griller smoker.

Weber Smokey Mountain
Kamado
Traeger

Point Totals

Weber Smokey Mountain – 60

Char-Griller Kamado – 75

Traeger Smoker – 95

The Traeger Smoker has the most advanced temperature control out of these three options. You can set the temperature from low all the way to 450 degrees F and the controller will maintain the temperature for you.

This means that you won’t have to stand by the unit all day long when it is cooking your food, you can rest easy knowing that it will maintain the temperature without your help. You’ll also love that the temperature is shown in an LED display so you can quickly tell the temperature without worrying about checking the gauge.

Final Score

Weber Smokey Mountain – 170

Char-Griller Kamado – 215

Traeger Smoker – 250

Overall, the Traeger Smoker is the most advanced griller smoker on this list. Not only is it incredibly versatile so you can use it to make food in some ways, but it is incredibly easy to use.

With a considerable grilling area that can easily grill 12 hamburgers at a time, as well as an electronic ignition that is auto-start, this griller smoker will take the place of any other outdoor cooking equipment that you have in your home.

It’s durable and rugged, able to withstand years of use before you experience any problems, and the sawhorse design gives you all of the stability that you need when using it.

Weber Smokey Mountain

Positives
  • 10 Year Warranty
  • Stainless Steel
  • Built In Thermometer
  • 2 Cooking Grates

Negatives
  • Weight
  • Temperature Control

Positives
  • Solid Steel Construction
  • Side Shelf
  • Triple Wall Insulation
  • Warming Rack

Negatives
  • Temperature Control
  • Assembly Needed

Positives
  • Digital Temperature Control
  • Electronic Ignition
  • Steel Construction
  • Versatile

Negatives
  • Price
  • Single Wall Insulation

Our Choice

When comparing the Weber Smokey Mountain and the Komado and the Trager smokers, we feel that you can’t go wrong with Traeger Smoker, but it is more expensive. If money is no obstacle, then we choose the Traeger Smoker.

For More Information About Weber Gas Grills And For The Best Price Online, Check Out These Articles

Read This Weber Smokey Mountain vs Kamado vs Traeger Comparison To Discover The Information YOU Are Searching For. We Have The Best Meat Smoker Comparisons On The Net! #food #cooking #cookingtips #Smokedmeat #meatsmokers #TabersBestReviews

Duke Taber is the owner of 3 successful websites and is now taking his skill as a writer and using it to help non-profit organizations and leaders around the world.

      Pin
      Share
      Tweet